In February 2016, Farhad Moshiri purchased his 49.9% stake of Everton football club, with a look to making them into a Premier League powerhouse, having invested nearly a quarter of a million pounds over the space of five transfer windows.
The Iranian businessman now owns 68.6% of the blue side of Liverpool, but the club are still stuck in the middle of the pack, and signings by and large haven’t lived up to the hype, especially when attempting to replacing Romelu Lukaku. Here’s a rundown of all of the signings Everton have made in the Moshiri era, and how they’ve performed in their Angry Birds shirts.
Summer 2016
Yannick Bolasie – £28 million from Crystal Palace
When he arrived on the back of an eyecatching season at Sellhurst Park, Yannick Bolasie was Everton’s most expensive transfer of all time. The DR Congo international started the season well and supplied Everton with some decent wide play, but his year was cut short as a cruciate ligament injury ruled him out for a year, hugely unfortunate for both the man and the club. Now on a season long loan at Villa looking to recover some fitness and form.
Rating: C

Ashley Williams – £14 million from Swansea
The man who’s most memorable moment in an Everton shirt was inciting a brawl in which a father tried to punch a Lyon player whilst holding his child in the other arm. The assurance and leadership he offered at Swansea never came to fruition in blue and instead he had an adverse effect on the defensive line, and co-centre back Michael Keane in particular. Now on loan and doing a terrible job at Stoke.
Rating: F

Idrissa Gana Gueye – £8.5 million from Aston Villa
Gueye arrived at Everton and quickly became a budget version of N’Golo Kante. He made the highest number of successful tackles and interceptions per match across Europe’s top five leagues in 2016 and has continually been a shining performer in the centre of the park for Everton. For all his defensive mastery, it must also be said that he carries the ball very well and often contributes to attacks by bringing the wingers into the play. The best Moshiri signing of them all.
Rating: A

Dominic Calvert-Lewin – £2 million from Sheffield United
Having amassed 47 Premier League appearances at the ripe young age of 21, DCL has been a pleasantly surprising signing for Moshiri and company. He offers pace and tenacity both wide or through the centre, however his first touch can be serverly lacking at time and he still needs to show more cutting edge in the final third. Still has plenty of time to develop under Marco Silva.
Rating: B

Maarten Steklenburg – £1 million from Fulham
Saved two penalties in one game against Manchester City but did very little else after linking up with fellow Dutchman Ronald Koeman. Still a solid enough backup for Pickford, especially at the cheap price.
Rating: C

Enner Valencia – Loan from West Ham United
Bought in as a cheap back up for Romelu Lukaku, scoring 3 in 21 games, nothing else worth noting as he performed as averagely as expected. There was an option to buy following the loan, but 17 million for mediocrity would have been a rip off. Now at Tigres UANL in Mexico with a good record of 15 goals in 38 games.
Rating: D

Winter 2017
Morgan Schneiderlin – £23 million from Manchester United
After struggling to make any waves at United, Schneiderlin moved to Everton and so far has suffered a similar fate. He has started a number of games at Goodison Park but struggled under Koeman and Allardyce especially. Marco Silva has assured the Frenchman he has a future at Everton so hopefully he can push on a rediscover some of the quality play that made him a standout in his Southampton side.
Rating: E

Ademola Lookman – £9 million from Charlton
An impressive talent that should be getting far more game time, either at Everton or elsewhere. Allardyce disillusioned Lookman and Silva must have done some solid convincing to keep the 20 year old from returning to the Bundesliga where he was excellent for Red Bull Leipzig, but it seems weird that he still picked up Bernard with Lookman in the wings. Obviously one for the future, but it hasn’t been smooth sailing so far and it feels likely that he may want to return to Germany where he had increased appearances.
Rating: D

Summer 2017
Gylfi Sigurdsson – £50 million from Swansea
The first of many signings which led people to believe Everton had ‘won’ the transfer window, despite the gaping Lukaku shaped hole in the squad. Gylfi suffered from there being too many cooks spoiling the centre attacking midfield pot, and with Rooney taking the central role, the Icelandic talisman was left to struggle in a wide role, akin to his time at Tottenham. He scored an absolute banger from 50 yards on his full debut and performed well when played centrally. This season he has started very well, including a very impressive showing against Southampton.
Rating: B

Michael Keane – £28 million from Burnley
Keane arrived at Everton as year after the departure of John Stones, and looked to provide the defensive steel needed after a much celebrated season at Burnley. He’s had a few injuries and unfortunately had to try an form a pairing with Ashely Williams, so things haven’t been great and he hasn’t found the solidity that made Everton pick him up for almost £30 milion, but he clearly has the qualities needed and he could end up forming a fruitful partnership with Yerry Mina or Kurt Zouma.
Rating: C

Jordan Pickford – £28 million from Sunderland
It’s bad timing for a good review after his blunder at the weekend, but Jordan Pickford has been a saviour for Everton since joining and dragged then to a result in multiple games, most notably under Allardyce. Top showings last season established him at England’s number one for the World Cup, outshining Nick Pope, Joe Hart and Jack Butland to get the prestigious spot. Plus, at the age of 24 he could quite probably be Everton’s keeper for the next 10 years, so he’s a steal at £28 million.
Rating: A

Davy Klaasen – £27 million from Ajax
I feel sorry for Davy Klassen, he came with so much hype after helping Ajax to a Europa League final and nothing went o plan for him in England. Rooney was playing in his position, he was frozen out by Sam Allardyce after the departure of Ronald Koeman and this summer he was sold to Weder Bremen for half of what the blues paid for him. A huge fall from grace from a man who is now destined to be on lists such as ‘Top 10 Premier League flops’ for the rest of rest of time.
Rating: F

Nikola Vlasic – £10 million from Hadjuk Split
At 20 years of age he’s got a shedload of time to develop and cement a place in a future Everton line up after being a bit part player for the whole season. Now on loan and getting games at CSKA Moscow.
Rating: D

Henry Onyekuru – £8 million from K.A.S. Eupen
Seemingly a player that Moshiri’s men bought in to farm out on loan forever and eventually try and sell at a profit. Last season he had a good record of 9 goals in 19 league games for Anderlecht and this year he’s already bagged 2 goals in 3 showings for Galatasaray. I understand he’s young and fairly inexperienced but when Everton were, and still are, suffering from somewhat of a striking crisis, loaning out someone who at least has goals in him, seems bizarre.
Rating: E

Sandro Ramirez – £6 million from Malaga
Hailed as one of the bargains of the summer beforehand but never took flight in the Premier League and has now appeared in 21 league games (both for Everton and Sevilla) without scoring a single goal. Now he’s back out on loan at Real Sociedad and hasn’t made an appearance yet. Hopefully he can re-find his feet and return to Everton strong; that’s pretty much a pipedream though.
Rating: E

Cuco Martina – Free from Southampton
Cuco ‘remember that wonder goal against Arsenal’ Martina followed Ronald Koeman to Everton from Southampton and did an okayish job of filling in for the injured Seamus Coleman. He worked hard and made 28 appearances across all competitions but was quite clearly not a suitable right back for a team challenging for a European place. Stoke have since taken him on loan where he will presumably find his level.
Rating: C
![]()
Wayne Rooney – Free from Manchester United
Despite creating as many problems as he solved, in that he was the main reason why Klaassen failed to get games and Sigurdsson was forced to ply his trade out wide. Rooney himself though looked somewhat revitalised back at Goodison Park and returned a healthy 10 goals in 31 Premier League fixtures, making him their top scorer. He was tenacious and hardworking as expected, and will mostly be remembered in his second stint at Everton for completing his hattrick against West Ham United with a superb long rang strike. If they had a proper striker and pacey wingers around him he would likely have been able to perform even better. Now he’s in the twilight of his career at DC United in the MLS, where he seems to be having a frankly lovely time.
Rating: B

Winter 2018
Theo Walcott – £22 million from Arsenal
The best of the winter signings looks very comfortable in an Everton shirt. Walcott has provided much needed width, pace and quality ball control to a side that was completely static beforehand; his final product, be it a cross or a shot, can still be stale at times but he’s working well in the system and will likely thrive under the extremely forward thinking Marco Silva. Still feels wrong that he’s 29 years of age though.
Rating: B

Cenk Tosun – £22 million from Besiktas
The man signed to fill the void left behind by Romelu Lukaku hasn’t truly adapted to life in England’s top flight yet. After 5 goals in 14 at the back end of the last term, he’s started supremely poorly this year and has completely lost his eye for goal, consistently missing chances that others have put on a silver platter for him. The issue again is, who else do Everton have up front? They’ve gone all in on Tosun and Oumar Niasse is no better than him. This striker issue looks set to rumble on and it feels very similar to the Moyes era when the never had the patented 20 goals per season striker they desperately required.
Rating: E

Eliaquim Mangala – Loan from Manchester City
Joined, played two games, got injured, returned to City. Nothing more to say on this one.
Rating: F

Summer 2018
Here we are now then, I’m not going to rate all the signings for this window because they’ve only played a handful of games thus far, but I’ll give a quick overview as to how they’re doing or expected to do.
Richarlison has settled instantly and is already the most important player in this Everton side, providing goals and flair which nobody else can. Zouma, on loan from Chelsea, struggled against West Ham alongside Holgate but otherwise has looked pretty composed in a system which doesn’t benefit defenders too much; when Mina is finally fit enough, Zouma, Mina and Keane could form a powerful and athletic back line for Silva.
Bernard should add more energy up top and allow for rotation of wingers throughout the campaign and if Andre Gomes can find his Valencia form he will be a gem in the centre of the park alongside the robust Idrissa Gueye. Finally, Lucas Digne looks fantastic on the ball but will likely get caught out in the spaces behind him due to the system Everton now play, regardless, he’s an upgrade on the aging Leighton Baines.

Overall then the signings made under Moshiri haven’t been up to scratch aside from a few diamonds in the rough. Gueye, Rooney and Pickford all performed well, and Sigurdsson, Walcott and Richarlison are now playing a system designed to get the best out of them, so surely they will blossom too. The rest however, have been middling at best and are unlikely to feature too much given the new blood that Silva has introduced. Davy Klaassen in particular will go down as one of the most lacklustre signatures in Premier League history.
The biggest question hangs over the frontman. Tosun’s confidence is in the toilet and there’s no quality alternative the side can turn to bang in a few goals; securing a deal for a quality, confident finisher should be the number on priority in winter, even if Tosun somehow picks up in form. Moshiri hasn’t been afraid to invest, the club just need to be smarter with their business and buy players that fit correctly into the Silva system.















